Services
Coverage Built Around Your Life
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
About Us
A Local Team That Actually Shows Up for You
We’re not a 1-800 number.
We’re right here in your community.
When it comes to insurance, who you work with matters.
You deserve more than a call center or an online form — you deserve a team that knows your name, understands your situation, and is there when you need real help.
At the Lehmann Insurance Agency, we focus on building long-term relationships with the individuals and families we serve. That means taking the time to explain your coverage, answer your questions, and make sure you feel confident in your decisions — not just today, but for years to come.
- Based in New Berlin, serving all of Southeastern Wisconsin
- We meet in person, over the phone, or however you prefer
- Bilingual team to better serve our community
- Active in local charities, events, and outreach
Insurance shouldn’t feel complicated or impersonal.
It should feel like you have a trusted advisor in your corner — someone who’s looking out for your best interests at every stage of life.
We believe insurance should be personal, accessible, and built on relationships — not transactions.
A Simple Process Designed Around You
Request a Quote
Tell us a little about your current situation. Share some basic details about your home, vehicles, or current coverage. Whether you’re starting fresh or comparing options, we’ll use this to begin building a personalized recommendation.
Get a Coverage Review
We analyze what you have and identify gaps or opportunities. We take a close look at your current policies and walk through your needs. Our goal is to make sure you’re not underinsured — and that you fully understand how your coverage works.
Choose With Confidence
We walk you through your options so you can make the right decision. We’ll explain your options clearly, answer your questions, and help you choose coverage that fits your situation — not just the lowest price, but the right protection.
Ongoing Support
We’re here when you need us — policy changes, claims, questions, and more. Our relationship doesn’t end after you sign up. Whether you need to update your policy, have a question, or file a claim, you’ll have a local team ready to help.
Free Download
The Wisconsin Homeowner’s Maintenance Calendar
Inside you’ll discover:
- Monthly maintenance checklists
- Seasonal homeowner tips
- Preventative maintenance reminders
- Home protection insights
- Emergency preparedness recommendations
Download your FREE copy today and keep your home in top condition all year long.
Testimonials
What our clients say
Our Blog
Latest news from
The Lehmann Agency
10 Ways to Lower Your Auto Insurance Rates in Wisconsin (Without Cutting Coverage)
There are several ways to lower your auto insurance premiums without sacrificing the coverage that protects your family financially. In Wisconsin, I would focus on discounts, deductibles, vehicle usage, and how your policy is structured before considering reductions...
Does Hitting a Deer Increase Your Auto Insurance Rates in Wisconsin?
What Wisconsin Drivers Need to Know About Deer Accidents, Insurance Coverage, and Potential Rate Increases Wisconsin drivers know that deer can appear on the road without warning. Whether you're driving through rural Wisconsin or traveling along busy roads in...
Wisconsin Salvage Title Laws: Could a Previously Totaled Vehicle Still Have a Clean Title?
What Wisconsin drivers need to know about salvage titles, rebuilt vehicles, accident history, and how our laws compare to neighboring states. When shopping for a used vehicle, most buyers look at mileage, mechanical condition, accident history, and price. But there's...